The Greatest Baseball Players of All-Time

The Overflow

*Does not include active players

Josh BeckettGabby HartnettBobby Abreu
Vida BlueElston HowardMoises Alou
Bert BlylevenJoe MauerGarrett Anderson
Kevin BrownYadier MolinaRichie Ashburn
Mordecai BrownThurman MonsonEarl Averill
Mark BuerhleJorge PosadaJose Bautista
Madison BumgarnerBuster PoseyDon Baylor
Jim BunningTed SimmonsHarold Baines
John ClarksonJoe TorreAlbert Belle
Bartolo ColonDick AllenCarlos Beltran
David ConeCap AnsonWally Berger
Stan CoveleskiJake BeckleyBobby Bonds
Mike CuellarLance BerkmanRyan Braun
Dizzy DeanJim BottomleyLou Brock
Doug DrabekDan BrouthersJesse Burkett
Don DrysdaleNorm CashEllis Burks
Chuck FinleyOrlando CepedaJose Canseco
Lefty GomezWill ClarkMax Carey
Dwight GoodenRoger ConnorJack Clark
Zack GreinkeCecil CooperFred Clarke
Ron GuidryCarlos DelgadoRocky Colavito
Cole HamelsDarrell EvansGravvy Cravath
Felix HernandezCecil FielderSam Crawford
Orel HershiserPrince FielderNelson Cruz
Tim HudsonAndres GalarragaKiki Cuyler
Catfish HunterSteve GarveyJohnny Damon
Tommy JohnJason GiambiChili Davis
Addie JossAdrian GonzalezAndre Dawson
Jim KaatMark GraceEd Delahantay
Tim KeefeTodd HeltonLarry Doby
Jimmy KeyKeith HernandezHugh Duffy
Corey KluberGil HodgesAdam Dunn
John LackeyRyan HowardJim Edmonds
Cliff LeeKent HrbekDwight Evans
Bob LemonPaul KonerkoElmer Flick
John LesterDerrek LeeGeorge Foster
Tim LincecumTino MartinezKirk Gibson
Ted LyonsDon MattinglyBrian Giles
Juan MarichalLee MayJuan Gonzalez
Dennis MartinezFred McGriffLuis Gonzalez
Jim McCormickJustin MorneauGoose Goslin
Joe McGinnityJohn OlerudPedro Guerrero
Denny McLainTony PerezHarry Heilman
Dave McNallyBoog PowellBabe Herman
Jack MorrisRoy SieversMatt Holliday
Mike MussinaGeorge SislerFrank Howard
Don NewcombeMark TeixeiraTorii Hunter
Kid NicholsBill TerryJoe Jackson
Phil NiekroMo VaughnAndruw Jones
Roy OswaltRoberto AlomarDavid Justice
Gaylord PerryCraig BiggioWillie Keeler
Jim PerryRobinson CanoKing Kelly
Andy PettitteEddie CollinsRalph Kiner
Eddie PlankNellie FoxChuck Klein
Rick ReuschelFrankie FrischCarlos Lee
Jose RijoCharlie GehringerGreg Luzinski
Kenny RogersJoe GordonFred Lynn
CC SabathiaBobby GrichHeinie Manush
Bret SaberhagenBilly HermnRoger Maris
Dave StewartJeff KentAndrew McCutchen
Dave StiebTony LazzeriJoe Medwick
Rick SutcliffeBill MazeroskiMinnie Minoso
Don SuttonJackie RobinsonKevin Mitchell
Luis TiantRyne SandbergDale Murphy
Fernando ValenzuelaRed SchoendienstTony Oliva
Dazzy VanceLou WhitakerAl Oliver
Rube WaddellLuis AparicioPaul O’Neil
Adam WainwrightLuke ApplingMagglio Ordonez
Ed WalshLou BoudreauJim O’Rourke
Brandon WebbDave ConcepcionDave Parker
Bob WelchJoe CroninVada Pinson
David WellsGeorge DavisKirby Puckett
Wilbur WoodBarry LarkinTim Raines
Early WynnPee Wee ReeseJim Rice
Rollie FingersJimmy RollinsSam Rice
Eric GagneOzzie SmithTim Salmon
Rich GossageMiguel TejadaAl Simmons
Trevor HoffmanAlan TrammellKen Singleton
Craig KimbrelArky VaughanSam Thompson
Mike MarshallBobby WallaceEnos Slaughter
Randy MyersRobin YountReggie Smith
Joe NathanHome Run BakerDuke Snider
Jon PapelbonRon CeyAlfonso Soriano
Dan QuisenberryGary GaettiRusty Staub
Francisco RodriguezGeorge KellDarry Strawberry
Lee SmithBill MadlockBobby Veach
Bruce SutterJohn McGrawLarry Walker
Billy WagnerCraig NettlesPaul Waner
John WettelandAramis RamirezZack Wheat
Roy CampanellaScott RolenBernie Williams
Mickey CochraneAl RosenBilly Williams
Bill DickeyRon SantoHack Wilson
Buck EwingDeacon WhiteDave Winfield
Carlton FiskMatt WilliamsJim Wynn
Bill FreehanDavid WrightEdwin Encarnacion

Leave a Reply

Hi (hopefully) awesome reader! I welcome your comments. However, please be aware that I make all of my arguments using facts, statistics, and logic. Unfortunately, the average comment on a top-100 list goes something like this:

"UR StooPid. (Insert player) is trash. I've watched (pick a sport) for (pick a number of years) and (pick a player) is better than everyone. UR DUMB. HAHA6969."

–Some Jabroni

As cognitively stimulating as this species of comment is, it ends up being a missed opportunity to share a nuanced perspective. I reply to all comments that show even the most basic levels of thought and humility. The people who make the comments like the example above are under the assumption that the three seconds of thought that popped into their brains after reading the list is more than the 1000s of hours that I put into creating and maintaining the lists. I would be happy to defend any placement, or make an adjustment if one is warranted. If you are a jabroni, like the one above, then your comment will die in the lonely void of the unpublished comments section.

For everyone else, I look forward to your comments!

P.S. The theme of this site and the top-100 lists is that athletes from previous generations have historically been grossly overrated by sports publications in a way that is statistically improbable. Click on the "About" dropdown menu to see just how badly the average top-100 list disproportionately favors athletes from older generations when leagues were smaller, race quotas existed, and globalization wasn't a thing. Also, please consider reading "The History" section of the sport you are commenting on.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *