The Overflow
*Does not include active wrestlers
| Afa | Blackjack Lanza | |
| Adrian Adonis | Jushin Liger | |
| Ole Anderson | Magnum TA | |
| Tony Atlas | Dean Malenko | |
| The Big Boss Man | The Great Malenko | |
| Brutus “The Barber” Beefcake | Mil Mascaras | |
| Jerry Blackwell | Ricky Morton | |
| Tully Blanchard | Don Muraco | |
| Freddie Blassie | Dick Murdoch | |
| Dino Bravo | The Great Muta | |
| Bobo Brazil | One Man Gang | |
| Brian Pillman | Paul Orndorff | |
| King Kong Bundy | Bob Orton | |
| Edouard Carpentier | Ken Patera | |
| Carlos Colon | Pat Patterson | |
| Barry Darsow | Psicosis | |
| Shane Douglas | Ivan Putski | |
| Bubba Ray Dudley | Baron von Raschke | |
| “Hacksaw” Jim Duggan | Raven | |
| Earthquake | William Regal | |
| Bobby Eaton | Tommy Rich | |
| Bill Eadie | Rikishi | |
| David Von Erich | Alberto Del Rio | |
| Kerry Von Erich | Road Dogg | |
| Mr. Fuji | Road Warrior Animal | |
| Ronnie Garvin | Billy Robinson | |
| Robert Gibson | Antonino Rocca | |
| Eddie Gilbert | Mike Rotunda | |
| Terry Gordy | Tito Santana | |
| The Godfather | Ken Shamrock | |
| Eddie Graham | Sika | |
| Juventud Guerrera | George “The Animal” Steele | |
| Chavo Guerrero Jr. | Chief Jay Strongbow | |
| Michael Hayes | Braun Strowman | |
| Junkyard Dog | Big John Studd | |
| Gorilla Monsoon | Kevin Sullivan | |
| Haku | Taz | |
| Larry Hennig | Ultimo Dragon | |
| Mark Henry | Mad Dog Vachon | |
| Gino Hernandez | Greg “the Hammer” Valentine | |
| The Honky Tonk Man | Johnny Valentine | |
| The Iron Sheik | Jesse “The Body” Ventura | |
| Jeff Jarrett | Sid Vicious | |
| Rocky Johnson | Nikolai Volkoff | |
| Kamala | Whipper Billy Watson | |
| Steve Keirn | Dr. Death Steve Williams | |
| Konnan | Barry Windham | |
| Ivan Koloff | X Pac | |
| Ernie Ladd | Yokozuna | |
| Stan Lane | Larry Zybysko | |