The Overflow
*Does not include active players
| Josh Beckett | Elston Howard | Garrett Anderson |
| Vida Blue | Joe Mauer | Richie Ashburn |
| Bert Blyleven | Yadier Molina | Earl Averill |
| Kevin Brown | Thurman Monson | Jose Bautista |
| Mordecai Brown | Jorge Posada | Don Baylor |
| Mark Buerhle | Buster Posey | Harold Baines |
| Madison Bumgarner | Ted Simmons | Albert Belle |
| Jim Bunning | Joe Torre | Carlos Beltran |
| John Clarkson | Dick Allen | Wally Berger |
| Bartolo Colon | Cap Anson | Bobby Bonds |
| David Cone | Jake Beckley | Ryan Braun |
| Stan Coveleski | Lance Berkman | Lou Brock |
| Mike Cuellar | Jim Bottomley | Jesse Burkett |
| Dizzy Dean | Dan Brouthers | Ellis Burks |
| Doug Drabek | Norm Cash | Jose Canseco |
| Don Drysdale | Orlando Cepeda | Max Carey |
| Chuck Finley | Will Clark | Jack Clark |
| Lefty Gomez | Roger Connor | Fred Clarke |
| Dwight Gooden | Cecil Cooper | Rocky Colavito |
| Zack Greinke | Carlos Delgado | Gravvy Cravath |
| Ron Guidry | Darrell Evans | Sam Crawford |
| Cole Hamels | Cecil Fielder | Nelson Cruz |
| Felix Hernandez | Prince Fielder | Kiki Cuyler |
| Orel Hershiser | Andres Galarraga | Johnny Damon |
| Tim Hudson | Steve Garvey | Chili Davis |
| Catfish Hunter | Jason Giambi | Andre Dawson |
| Tommy John | Adrian Gonzalez | Ed Delahantay |
| Addie Joss | Mark Grace | Larry Doby |
| Jim Kaat | Todd Helton | Hugh Duffy |
| Tim Keefe | Keith Hernandez | Adam Dunn |
| Jimmy Key | Gil Hodges | Jim Edmonds |
| Corey Kluber | Ryan Howard | Dwight Evans |
| John Lackey | Kent Hrbek | Elmer Flick |
| Cliff Lee | Paul Konerko | George Foster |
| Bob Lemon | Derrek Lee | Kirk Gibson |
| John Lester | Tino Martinez | Brian Giles |
| Tim Lincecum | Don Mattingly | Juan Gonzalez |
| Ted Lyons | Lee May | Luis Gonzalez |
| Juan Marichal | Fred McGriff | Goose Goslin |
| Dennis Martinez | Justin Morneau | Pedro Guerrero |
| Jim McCormick | John Olerud | Harry Heilman |
| Joe McGinnity | Tony Perez | Babe Herman |
| Denny McLain | Boog Powell | Matt Holliday |
| Dave McNally | Roy Sievers | Frank Howard |
| Jack Morris | George Sisler | Torii Hunter |
| Mike Mussina | Mark Teixeira | Ichiro |
| Don Newcombe | Bill Terry | Joe Jackson |
| Kid Nichols | Mo Vaughn | Andruw Jones |
| Phil Niekro | Joey Votto | David Justice |
| Roy Oswalt | Roberto Alomar | Willie Keeler |
| Gaylord Perry | Craig Biggio | King Kelly |
| Jim Perry | Robinson Cano | Ralph Kiner |
| Andy Pettitte | Eddie Collins | Chuck Klein |
| Eddie Plank | Nellie Fox | Carlos Lee |
| Rick Reuschel | Frankie Frisch | Greg Luzinski |
| Jose Rijo | Charlie Gehringer | Fred Lynn |
| Kenny Rogers | Joe Gordon | Heinie Manush |
| CC Sabathia | Bobby Grich | Roger Maris |
| Bret Saberhagen | Billy Hermn | Andrew McCutchen |
| Dave Stewart | Jeff Kent | Joe Medwick |
| Dave Stieb | Tony Lazzeri | Minnie Minoso |
| Rick Sutcliffe | Bill Mazeroski | Kevin Mitchell |
| Don Sutton | Jackie Robinson | Dale Murphy |
| Luis Tiant | Ryne Sandberg | Tony Oliva |
| Fernando Valenzuela | Red Schoendienst | Al Oliver |
| Dazzy Vance | Lou Whitaker | Paul O’Neil |
| Rube Waddell | Luis Aparicio | Magglio Ordonez |
| Adam Wainwright | Luke Appling | Jim O’Rourke |
| Ed Walsh | Lou Boudreau | Dave Parker |
| Brandon Webb | Dave Concepcion | Vada Pinson |
| Bob Welch | Joe Cronin | Kirby Puckett |
| David Wells | George Davis | Tim Raines |
| Wilbur Wood | Barry Larkin | Jim Rice |
| Early Wynn | Pee Wee Reese | Sam Rice |
| Rollie Fingers | Jimmy Rollins | Tim Salmon |
| Eric Gagne | Ozzie Smith | Al Simmons |
| Rich Gossage | Miguel Tejada | Ken Singleton |
| Trevor Hoffman | Alan Trammell | Sam Thompson |
| Craig Kimbrel | Arky Vaughan | Enos Slaughter |
| Mike Marshall | Bobby Wallace | Reggie Smith |
| Randy Myers | Robin Yount | Duke Snider |
| Joe Nathan | Home Run Baker | Alfonso Soriano |
| Jon Papelbon | Ron Cey | Rusty Staub |
| Dan Quisenberry | Gary Gaetti | Darry Strawberry |
| Francisco Rodriguez | George Kell | Bobby Veach |
| Lee Smith | Bill Madlock | Larry Walker |
| Bruce Sutter | John McGraw | Paul Waner |
| Billy Wagner | Craig Nettles | Zack Wheat |
| John Wetteland | Aramis Ramirez | Bernie Williams |
| Roy Campanella | Scott Rolen | Billy Williams |
| Gary Carter | Al Rosen | Hack Wilson |
| Mickey Cochrane | Ron Santo | Dave Winfield |
| Bill Dickey | Deacon White | Jim Wynn |
| Buck Ewing | Matt Williams | Edwin Encarnacion |
| Carlton Fisk | David Wright | Edgar Martinez |
| Bill Freehan | Bobby Abreu | |
| Gabby Hartnett | Moises Alou |